
Mayo Clinic, which posted $1.5 billion in profit last year, received more in tax breaks than it spent on charity care and community investment of any other nonprofit hospital in the country.
The analysis comes from the Lown Institute, a nonpartisan think tank that ranks hospitals based on what it calls “fair share deficits.” Nonprofit hospitals like Mayo Clinic are exempt from taxes like federal and state income taxes and local property taxes. In exchange for this benefit, nonprofit medical institutions are legally required to subsidize care for eligible low-income patients and invest in actions that benefit the community.
The Lown Institute found Mayo Clinic spent $366 million less on community benefit items in fiscal year 2023 than it received in tax exemptions. That number is greater than any other nonprofit hospital in the U.S.
Gerard Anderson, a professor and director at Johns Hopkins Center for Hospital Finance and Management, said the disparity is something for Minnesotans to pay attention to.
“Minnesota and the federal government are giving [Mayo Clinic] a very large tax break, and the question is, what are they doing with that tax break?” Anderson asked. “Are they just paying much higher salaries, are they putting it into very large reserves or are they actually providing benefits to either the local community or everyone in the state of Minnesota?”
Anderson said Mayo Clinic’s charity care spending — money spent subsidizing care for low-income patients — is a particular outlier. While hospitals across the country spend about 4 percent of their revenue on subsidizing care for low-income patients, last year Mayo spent $157 million providing charity care, just 0.7 percent of its revenue.
Mayo Clinic is not the only hospital to skimp on community benefit spending. The Lown Institute analysis found that more than half of U.S. nonprofit hospitals received more in tax breaks than they spent on charity care and community investment. In fact, some of the country’s wealthiest hospitals made the Lown Institute’s top 10, including Stanford Hospital, Cleveland Clinic and Massachusetts General Hospital.
What counts as community benefit?
Many hospitals including Mayo Clinic dispute the Lown Institute’s findings.
“As a nonprofit academic medical center focused on patient care, research and education, Mayo Clinic provides substantial community benefits that the Lown Institute’s deeply flawed methodology fails to accurately represent,” a Mayo Clinic spokesperson said. “The methodology excludes important categories of Community Benefit identified by the IRS, including Medicaid shortfall, medical research and health professions education.”
“Mayo Clinic remains committed to improving the health and vitality of the people and the communities we serve while ensuring access to high-quality care for all patients and leading transformative innovation in medical research and education.”
But Anderson said the think tank’s ranking system is commonly used in his line of work and is known to be reliable and transparent.
“They rely on data to do their analysis,” Anderson said. “They take a look at information that’s publicly available, synthesize it in very accessible ways so that the public can understand what are the hospitals that are providing a lot of community benefit and charity care, and what are the hospitals that are not.”
Dr. Vikas Saini, CEO of the Lown Institute, said that Lown was intentional about not including items such as research dollars and physician training in its community benefit spending calculations. Research, for example, is often funded by corporate donors or federal grants, so to call that community benefit would be like double dipping, Saini said. And physician training is part of the job of running a hospital, he said.
Saini said counting these things as community benefit is not in line with the spirit of the federal law, which asks tax-exempt hospitals to put extra money behind items outside of hospital operations that substantially improve the healthcare of the local community — the community that shoulders the burden of Mayo’s massive tax exemption.

The Lown Institute found some more financially-strapped hospitals, like Hennepin County Medical Center in the Twin Cities, spent more on patient financial assistance than Mayo Clinic did. HCMC, which was in financial straits and at risk of closing earlier this year, spent $9 million more on patient financial assistance in 2023 than Mayo did.
Saini said it’s important that the Lown Institute keep publishing its research to spread awareness.
“It’s crystal clear to almost everybody that the American healthcare system, while it has enormous strengths, has serious, serious problems,” Saini said. “We do this to trigger conversations, the kind of conversations that will happen as more people understand how the system works. The first step is understanding the problem.”
What can Mayo Clinic do to improve its community benefit spending?
Mayo has improved its patient financial assistance spending in recent years. It’s now triple where it was in 2021. But Anderson said there’s more to be done.
There’s lots of different work Mayo Clinic could do to meet this requirement, like conducting research that’s not already sponsored, funding a food bank, holding workshops for caregivers across the country or training health workers how to meet with people in rural areas with chronic conditions like diabetes or congestive heart failure, Anderson said.
“What [Mayo Clinic is] required to do under the Affordable Care Act is to say, ‘What are the needs of the community?’ And they could define the community as broad or as narrow as they want. And then once they have identified the needs, then they should put serious dollars behind their assessment of the needs,” Anderson said.
“What we see in many hospitals is there’s no link between their description of the needs of the community and their expenditures for the community,” he said. “I want to see that if they identify a problem, they actually put money behind solving the problem.”